Claims Service

Teagle Insurance is here when you need us most. If you have questions regarding your policy or claim please do not hesitate to contact us.

Our team is here to help in the event of a claim. For your convenience, you may also contact your carrier directly to report a claim using the provided contact information below. Please make sure you have your policy number available prior to calling.

Protecting your family is your priority. Serving YOU is our policy. Please do not hesitate to contact us if you need further assistance at 804-824-9886.

Personal & Commercial

American Modern
Website
Claims Phone: (800) 375-2075

American Strategic Insurance Company
Website
Claims Phone: (866) 274-5677

Bass Underwriters
Website
Claims Email: claims@bassuw.com

Chubb
Website
Claims Phone: (800) 252-4670

Foremost
Website
Claims Phone: (800) 274-786

Hagerty Insurance
Website
Claims Phone: (800) 922-4050

Hartford
Website
Claims Phone: (800) 243-5860

Grange
Website
Claims Phone: (800) 445-3030

Johnson and Johnson
Claims Phone: (800) 487-7565
Claims Email: claims@ijjns.com

Liberty Mutual
Website
Claims Phone: (800) 225-2467

Main Street America
Website
Claims Phone: (877) 425-2467

Mercury Insurance Company
Website
Claims Phone: (800) 503-3724

National General
Website
Claims Phone: (800) 468-3466

Nationwide
Website
Claims Phone: (800) 421-3535

Neptune
Website
Claims Phone: (727) 202-4815

Next Insurance
Website
Claims Phone: (800) 421-3535

Progressive Insurance
Website
Claims Phone: (800) 776-4737

Scottsdale
Claims Phone: (800) 423-7675

Selective Flood
Website
Claims Phone: (866) 455-9969

Safeco Insurance Company
Website
Claims Phone: (800) 332-3226

Tapco Underwriters
Claims Phone: (800) 334-5579
Claims Email: claims@gotapco.com

Travelers Insurance Company
Website
Claims Phone: (800) 252-4633

Universal Property & Casualty
Website
Claims Phone: (800) 470-0599