Your local, preferred, independent agency for over 30 years

Teagle Insurance Agency began serving the local community back in 1985 when founder Jeanell LaFata first opened the doors in a small office off of Route 17 in Ordinary. What started a small, one woman show quickly expanded as the needs for an independent agency in our community grew.

Over the years the agency has evolved it’s technology, expanded partnerships and gained a total of six fantastic agents who make up the agency today. (Pictured left: President, Jeanell LaFata & Sydney Early – daughter/Vice President)

At Teagle Insurance our clients get the best of both worlds. We’re small enough to take the time and really evaluate each of our clients’ portfolios and we’re large enough to work with the best insurance companies, utilize the latest technology and risk management techniques – ensuring the best overall experience. We work hard to understand our clients’ needs and provide them with innovative and highly individualized solutions.

We are conveniently located in the Gloucester courthouse to best serve Gloucester and surrounding areas. As an agency, our goal is to build lasting relationships with our clients who trust us to handle all of their insurance needs. We take pride in delivering unparalleled customer service, whether it’s for your personal or business needs, you can count on us!

Our Carriers

Coverage that’s unique as you

Because insurance is not one size fits all

As an independent agency, it all starts with you, the client. We listen to you and your needs and find the solution best for you because insurance is not one size fits all.

Personal Lines

  • Homeowners
  • Auto
  • Life
  • Flood
  • Umbrella
  • Boat
  • RV
  • Motorcycle
  • Renters
  • Landlord
  • Condo
  • Classic Car
  • Valuable Possessions
  • Event/Wedding
  • Travel
  • Pet

Commercial Lines

  • Business Owners
  • Workers Compensation
  • Inland Marine
  • General Liability
  • Commercial Property
  • Business Auto
  • Cyber Liability
  • Bonds
  • Commercial Umbrella
  • Errors & Omissions
  • Directors & Officers
  • Employment Practice Liability
  • Ocean Marine
  • Liquor Liability
  • Builders Risk
  • Crime

If you’re looking for something not specifically listed, chances are, we can do it! With our access to multiple markets, we provide every customer with the best possible service, even if it means we work a little harder or have to get creative to find the right solution.