Your Team

Originally from Newport News, Sarah moved to Gloucester in 2007. She's the glue that holds our team together on a daily basis as our customer service representative. Her favorite part about working at Teagle is our community involvement and how easy we make insurance for our clients. 

Jeanell LaFata, President


Since 1985, Jeanell has worked continuously in the insurance field. From managing, then starting her own insurance agency in the late 1980’s, her ambitious drive and determination helped grow the agency into what is now known as Teagle Insurance Agency. Along with working in the insurance field, Jeanell spends time in managing a few residential and commercial properties. She enjoys spending time with her family, fishing & crabbing, relaxing on the pier or boating.


Jennifer Wright, Producer /Agent


Jennifer Wright entered the insurance industry after raising and homeschooling her four children. She is a licensed Property and Casualty agent with a love for people. Her desire is to provide her clients with the best customer service while meeting their individual insurance needs.

Jennifer resides in Gloucester with her husband John. Their greatest joy comes from spending time with their family, friends and serving others at church and in the community.

Tonia Sibley, Producer/ Agent




Tonia Sibley, prior to joining our team, worked as a liability claims adjuster for a nationally recognized insurance company. Tonia is a licensed Property & Casualty producer and enjoys helping the local citizens with their insurance needs. Tonia is a resident of Middlesex County, where she resides with her husband, Blair, and their two children. Tonia and Blair enjoy attending their son’s baseball games, supporting their daughter in her academic achievements, fishing with the kids, and relaxing in the Outer Banks.